Copy Book Archive

Bede and the Paschal Controversy The earliest Christians longed to celebrate the resurrection together at Passover, but that was not as easy as it sounds.

In two parts

700-735
Roman Empire (Byzantine Era) 330 - 1453 to Anglo-Saxon Britain 410-1066
Music: George Frideric Handel

© Darren Rosson, Geograph. Licence: CC-BY-SA 2.0. Source

About this picture …

The moon over Maker Heights near Cremyll, Cornwall. To the right is the tower of the parish church of St Julian in the village of Maker, built in the 15th century.

Bede and the Paschal Controversy

Part 1 of 2

To keep Easter together during the Biblical festival of Passover was the shared dream of all the earliest Christian churches. But everyone seemed to have questions about how and when to celebrate the most important feast of the year, and no one seemed to have answers.

IN 325, bishops from around the world gathered at Nicaea near Constantinople, and one of the topics discussed was Easter. Christ died and rose again at Passover, the week-long Jewish festival at the first full moon of Spring, and Christians had always wanted to celebrate Easter at that time each year.

But no astronomer could determine the northern vernal equinox or a full moon with precision, and Jewish calendars were an unsatisfactory clutter of leaps and intercalary months.

Most churches kept Easter on a Sunday, the historical day of resurrection – if that was the first day of Passover, out of respect for the crucifixion they waited another week – but not everyone thought this important.*

The Nicene Council confirmed the tradition of a Sunday in Passover, and forbade routinely pegging the date to whatever the synagogue did; but nothing more was said about determining Passover itself. With astronomy in its infancy, and competing mathematical solutions already circulating, there was still plenty of work ahead.

Jump to Part 2

Passover may begin on any day of the week. The fact that Jesus was crucified on a Friday meant that his resurrection ‘on the third day’ (counting the day of crucifixion as the first) came sometime in the very early hours of Sunday, known even now in Greek as “Kiriaki”, the Lord’s Day, or in Russian as “Voskresen’ye”, Day of Resurrection.

Part Two

© Anne Burgess, Geograph. Licence: CC-BY-SA 2.0. Source

About this picture …

Pussy willow in flower, a sure sign of Spring in northern climes. In England until quite recently, and still in Russia, willows were brought to church for Palm Sunday, a week before Easter. Bede tells us that one Palm Sunday in the middle of the seventh century, Northumbria’s Queen Eanflaed was still fasting for Lent while her husband King Oswy was celebrating Easter with the Irish church.

THE work was soon done. When Roman missionaries came to Kent in 597, they introduced handy tables devised in Alexandria for determining the Paschal moon, and March 21st as a convenient first day of Spring.

Nonetheless, older methods remained in circulation, and in 635 St Aidan brought a peculiarly Irish one to Northumbria.* Seven years later, the two calendars collided, after King Oswy of Northumbria married Eanflaed, granddaughter of King Ethelbert of Kent. Oswy adopted Eanflaed’s Roman Easter in 664, convinced by a Synod in Whitby of its superiority.*

The Synod acquired international significance in 725 when Bede, a Northumbrian monk, published a brilliant treatise on the Paschal maths of Rome and the East. Europe was completely won over by it; and soon the Englishman had the whole Church, East and West, keeping the day of Christ’s bright resurrection together at Passover. “God has made Bede rise from the West” exclaimed Notker the Stammerer in Switzerland “as a new Sun to illuminate the whole Earth”.*

Copy Book

The Irish Easter was calculated accoring to an idiosyncratic system with roots in fourth-century Gaul and Rome. They allowed Easter Sunday to fall on the first day of Passover or even the day before, which some thought obscured the crucifixion, and their celebrations also lasted just one day, whereas for many churches worldwide Easter had always been a three-day event.

The argument was based on maths, the Nicene Council, and on what St Peter would have wanted. See The Synod of Whitby. Rome herself had been persuaded to come into line in part by St Ambrose of Milan, after their Easters did not match in 386. Work continued, and by the later fifth century the calculation devised at Alexandria commanded universal respect, except for some pockets of resistance such as Ireland.

For the story of how Bede’s hard-won harmony was broken in the 16th century, see The Calendar ‘English Style’.

Source

Based on ‘A History of the English Church and People’, by St Bede of Jarrow (early 8th century), and the documents of the First Council of Nicæa (AD 325).

Suggested Music

1 2

Chandos Anthems No. 9 (‘O Praise the Lord With One Consent’)

1. O Praise the Lord With One Consent

George Frideric Handel (1685-1759)

Performed by The Sixteen, on period instruments, directed by Harry Christophers.

Media not showing? Let me know!

Transcript / Notes

O PRAISE the Lord with one consent, and magnify his name.
Let all the servants of the Lord his worthy praise proclaim.

The text is from Psalm 135 in the Tate and Brady translation. The melody is strongly reminiscent of the popular hymn ‘O God our help in ages past’, and likewise of the first subject of Johann Sebastian Bach’s ‘St Anne Fugue’; however, Handel had already used this same motif a year before the hymn was published in 1708.

Chandos Anthems No. 9 (‘O Praise the Lord With One Consent’)

5. With cheerful notes

George Frideric Handel (1685-1759)

Performed by The Sixteen, on period instruments, directed by Harry Christophers.

Media not showing? Let me know!

Related Posts

for Bede and the Paschal Controversy

Anglo-Saxon Era

The Bishop and the Chatterbox

One week into a Lenten retreat with the Bishop of Hexham, a boy’s miserable life is turned right around.

Lives of the Saints

St Bede of Wearmouth and Jarrow

The mild-mannered, artistic monk was nevertheless a founding father of the English nation.

Lives of the Saints

St Aidan Returns King Penda’s Fire

When Penda tried to burn down Bamburgh Castle, St Aidan turned the pagan King’s own weapons against him.

Anglo-Saxon Era

King Edwin and the Hand of Destiny

Forced from his throne and threatened with murder, Edwin makes a curious bargain for his deliverance.

Lives of the Saints (186)
All Stories (1522)
Worksheets (14)
Word Games (5)